My Amazon Guy vs Canopy

Who Earns Your Trust?

Stuck choosing between Amazon agencies?  

Tired of empty promises and hidden agendas?  

You need clear facts, not marketing fluff.

This comparison will reveal which agency truly delivers for Amazon sellers.

Skip the comparison, and ignite your growth

My Amazon Guy vs Canopy: Who’s More Credible Online, Who Do Sellers Actually Trust?

The journey of an Amazon seller searching for the right agency often begins with an online search, looking for insights beyond client reviews and testimonials—seeking real feedback, discussions, and experiences that can provide a clearer picture of an agency’s true capabilities.

When you Google Canopy controversy, the first thing that shows up isn’t a track record of success. It’s a Reddit post exposing CEO Brian Burt for inflating his agency’s valuation with false numbers, his paid blue checkmark on Instagram, and allegations that Canopy pays to remove negative Glassdoor reviews.

My Amazon Guy vs Canopy Canopy Reddit controversy
Canopy Controversy on Reddit

And it doesn’t stop there. Another controversy floating around? Canopy sent a Cease and Desist letter to My Amazon Guy, accusing them of “interfering” with their business—because My Amazon Guy hired someone the Canopy owner had bullied. Let that sink in.

Meanwhile, yes, My Amazon Guy (MAG) has its share of Reddit debates, but here’s the difference—real clients, fans, and observers step in to set the record straight, sharing their wins and positive experiences with the agency. When you provide real results, people show up to defend you.

When a Reddit allegation claimed that Steven Pope runs a $20 million-a-year agency but struggles to make $20K a month on his own store, our clients quickly countered, sharing their own positive experiences of delivered results.

They pointed out that MAG delivers real results for their brands, with many seeing significant growth thanks to expert strategy, execution, and communication.

Rather than empty boasts, clients highlighted MAG’s transparency, responsiveness, and ability to solve complex Amazon challenges—proof that expertise isn’t measured by a single storefront, but by the success of the sellers we serve.

My Amazon Guy vs Canopy MAG client support on Reddit
MAG Clients Support Us On Reddit

Fans and observers also chimed in with their support, praising Steven’s Amazon expertise and the positive experience they’d had interacting with him.

My Amazon Guy vs Canopy MAG fan support on Reddit 1
MAG Fan Support Us On Reddit
My Amazon Guy vs Canopy MAG fan support on Reddit 2
MAG Fan Defends Us On Reddit

Who Has a Stronger Online & Social Media Presence?

Let’s get into the numbers:

Metric My Amazon Guy Canopy

Google SERPs

First-page presence

First-page presence (but not in a good way)

YouTube

53K subscribers, 2.5K+ videos

118 subscribers, 167 videos

LinkedIn

59K followers

4K followers

Facebook

7.7K followers

1.4K followers

Instagram

5,117 followers

1,201 followers

Twitter (X)

3,590 followers

40 followers

Pinterest

3.2K monthly views

36 monthly views

TikTok

731 followers

11 followers

Podcast Reach

On Apple, Spotify, Amazon Music, iHeartRadio, and 10+ other platforms

None

At this point, it’s not even a competition.

Why Social Media Presence Matters for Amazon Sellers

A strong online presence isn’t just about numbers—it’s about who’s actually helping sellers grow.

  • My Amazon Guy provides a massive library of free content—thousands of videos, blogs, and podcasts covering Amazon PPC, SEO, inventory issues, brand registry, and more.
  • The community is real and active. Thousands of sellers engage daily on LinkedIn, YouTube, and Facebook, asking questions and getting answers from experts.
  • Social proof matters. You don’t get 53K YouTube subscribers by accident. That’s years of valuable content, real engagement, and actual results.

On the flip side, Canopy is practically invisible in comparison. If they can’t even market themselves effectively, how are they supposed to market your Amazon brand?

Other MAG Executives: Leading the Conversation in the Amazon Space

At My Amazon Guy, our executives don’t just work behind the scenes—they’re actively engaged on social media, sharing insights, strategies, real-world solutions, and news updates for Amazon sellers. By staying visible and engaging with the seller community, we reinforce MAG’s authority as an industry leader, ensuring that both clients and followers benefit from our expertise.

Sellers Deserve an Agency That’s Transparent & Proven

If you want to work with an agency that’s not just talking about success but proving it daily—the choice is obvious.

My Amazon Guy vs Canopy: Which Agency Actually Delivers More for Sellers?

Choosing the right Amazon agency isn’t just about who sounds good—it’s about who actually delivers the services that help you grow. Let’s break down what My Amazon Guy and Canopy Management offer, and more importantly, what that means for your business.

Side-by-Side Service Comparison: Who Gives You More?

Service My Amazon Guy Canopy Management

✅ Weekly reports, check-ins, client calls

✅ 

✅ Includes DSP, PickFu A/B Testing, Facebook & TikTok Ads

✅ 4-Phase Process: Search Term Optimization, Indexing, Strike Zone Keywords, Market Share Growth

✅ Full Listing Overhaul, CTR Hacks, SEO Optimization

Brand guidelines, storefronts, listing images, A+ Content, Main Image CTR hacks

Inventory & Revenue Recovery

Clawback lost shipments, refund recovery (My Refund Guy)

Brand Growth & Protection

Customer Service Management

Customized Reporting

✅ Weekly reports, ad tracking, SEO progress

SOPs & Training Resources

Coaching & Consulting

✅ Detailed video audit of your listing with actionable steps

Live call + full campaign audit for free

✅ Data-backed main image testing for CTR optimization

Social Media & External Traffic

Proprietary Ad Software

✅ Canopy Ad Technology (CAT)

What Makes My Amazon Guy Stand Out?

  • We Give Free Value Before You Even Pay.

Want to know if your listing needs improvement? We offer a free, personalized ASIN Review—our Amazon experts record a video breaking down your PPC to SEO ratio, indexing, rankings, market share, traffic, conversion, and sales. No fluff—just straight-up analysis.

  • PPC Strategy Call – A Full Audit for Free.

Before you spend a dime, we analyze your ad strategy on a live call to spot campaign issues and provide a custom PPC plan to improve your targeting, bids, and ROI.

  • We Don’t Just Manage Your Amazon Store—We Help You Build a Brand.

We don’t stop at Amazon. Website SEO, email marketing, backlink building, Facebook & TikTok ads, A/B image testing— we help drive external traffic to your Amazon listings.

  • We Invest in the Best Tools & Talent.

Helium 10, Merchant Spring, industry events like PPC Summits, AMAs—we’re constantly upgrading our expertise and providing sellers with cutting-edge strategies.

What Does Canopy Offer?

Canopy’s Canopy Brand Plan™️ sounds impressive, but it’s just standard account management packaged under a fancy name. Their main unique offering is Canopy Ad Technology (CAT), an in-house PPC tool. But let’s be real—software alone doesn’t replace expert analysis.

Canopy covers the basics: account management, PPC, SEO, and Walmart services. But they lack crucial services that truly impact seller success:

  • No free ASIN audit or PPC strategy call
  • No advanced brand-building services (email marketing, backlinks, external traffic)
  • No trademark registration or refund recovery for lost shipments
  • No dedicated coaching or brand management SOPs

If all you want is an agency that runs PPC with an algorithm, Canopy’s software might work for you. But if you want real expertise, custom strategy, and full brand growth, My Amazon Guy is the clear choice.

Checklist: How to Pick the Right Amazon Agency

Before choosing an agency, ask yourself:

  • Do they offer free insights before I commit? (ASIN audit, PPC strategy call, free resources?)
  • Do they manage more than just my Amazon store? (SEO, email marketing, external traffic, brand growth?)
  • Can they actually help protect my brand legally? (Trademark registration, refund recovery, account reinstatement?)
  • Do they invest in real expertise, not just software? (SOPs, training programs, in-depth coaching?)
  • Is their leadership active, transparent, and engaging with sellers daily? (Or do they hide behind paid PR and scripted content?)

My Amazon Guy vs. Canopy: Do Clients See Real Results?

My Amazon Guy vs Canopy MAG agency figures
Our Amazon Agency's Outstanding Numbers

Revenue numbers don’t tell the full story. Canopy may boast $3.2 billion in managed revenue, but My Amazon Guy is more than just an agency that manages accounts—we’re an education powerhouse that equips sellers with the tools to grow.

At $1.2 billion in managed revenue, My Amazon Guy isn’t just focused on scaling brands—we teach sellers how to win. Our agency combines full-service brand management with a robust library of free and paid educational resources that help sellers succeed, whether they work with us or go the DIY route.

Results That Speak for Themselves: A Client Success Story

At My Amazon Guy, our strategies don’t just talk—they deliver. For example, take our work with K’lani, where we achieved:

1,218% increase in sales – A massive boost in revenue, demonstrating the effectiveness of our tailored approach.
56.6% reduction in ad cost – We optimized their advertising strategy to drive growth while lowering costs, proving that efficiency and results can go hand-in-hand.

We don’t just manage accounts—we educate, empower, and deliver.

Beyond Account Management: A Knowledge Hub for Sellers

My Amazon Guy vs Canopy MAG is an education company
My Amazon Guy: A Knowledge Base for Amazon Enthusiasts

Unlike Canopy, which primarily focuses on account management, My Amazon Guy offers a complete ecosystem of free and paid Amazon resources to help sellers understand, troubleshoot, and optimize their businesses.

🔹 Free Resources:

    • Live AMAs & YouTube Videos – Ask questions and get real-time insights from experts.
    • Articles & Infographics – Easy-to-digest guides on key Amazon strategies.
    • PPC Strategy Calls – Free audits to identify ad optimization opportunities.

🔹 Premium Resources:

    • MAG School Courses – Step-by-step training on brand management, PPC, SEO, and more.
    • Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) – Proven workflows for sellers and agencies.
    • Coaching Calls – Personalized guidance to solve complex Amazon challenges.
    • Success Academy – guided roadmap from product sourcing to Amazon scaling.

We believe that every seller deserves access to expert knowledge—whether they work with us or not.

My Amazon Guy vs Canopy MAG Amazon Resources Testimonial 2
We Offer Reliable Amazon Resources
My Amazon Guy vs Canopy MAG Amazon Resources Testimonial
Helpful Learning Materials, Accomodating CEO

Amazon Selling Tips You Can Use Today

Our expertise isn’t locked behind a paywall. We’ve shared hundreds of free, actionable strategies to help sellers improve their Amazon game. Here are some tips we shared online.

My Amazon Guy vs. Canopy: Does Agency Size Matter?

When choosing an Amazon agency, size isn’t just a number—it’s a game-changer for your business. My Amazon Guy and Canopy Management both launched in 2018, but the difference in team size is significant.

  • My Amazon Guy: 501-1000 employees (Atlanta, GA)
  • Canopy Management: 51-200 employees (Austin, TX)

Why Agency Size Matters for Your Amazon Business

A larger team means more resources, expertise, and support dedicated to growing your brand. Here’s how My Amazon Guy’s scale benefits you:

  • Dedicated Experts for Every Aspect of Your Brand

With a bigger team, you’re not relying on a handful of generalists. You get specialized professionals focused on each crucial area:

      • Brand Director & Brand Manager – Strategic leadership to drive long-term growth.
      • Project Manager – Ensures smooth execution of your Amazon strategy.
      • Amazon Specialists – Handles listing optimization, catalog troubleshooting, and account health.
      • Ad Specialists – Maximizes ROI with data-driven PPC campaigns.
      • Graphic Designers – Creates compelling images and A+ content to boost conversions.
  • A Powerhouse of Knowledge & Experience

More employees mean more brains working on solutions. Instead of just a few perspectives, you benefit from a team that has solved thousands of catalog issues, scaled brands from $0 to $10M+, and fine-tuned ad strategies that deliver real results.

  • Faster Problem-Solving & Execution

Amazon issues can tank your sales overnight. With a larger agency, you get rapid response times and a team that has likely seen—and fixed—your exact problem before. Whether it’s an unexpected ASIN suspension, suppressed listing, or declining ad performance, My Amazon Guy has the manpower to act fast.

More Employees = More Firepower for Your Brand

Both agencies are recognized for their growth, but My Amazon Guy’s larger team gives sellers a clear advantage—a full-scale Amazon growth machine ready to tackle every aspect of your business. When it comes to scaling on Amazon, bigger isn’t just better—it’s smarter.

My Amazon Guy vs Canopy: Who’s CEO is Actually Present & Helping Sellers?

Our CEO shit-posts. Theirs doesn’t even have 7,000 followers.

When choosing an Amazon agency, you’re not just hiring a company—you’re trusting the people behind it. And if a CEO isn’t actively engaged in the industry, how much do they really know?

Let’s compare:

CEO Steven Pope, My Amazon Guy Brian Burt, Canopy Management

LinkedIn Followers

58,671

6,996

Online Engagement

Thousands of videos, blogs, and podcast features

Minimal content

Industry Contributions

Shares strategies, case studies, and live Q&As

Rarely interacts publicly

Why an Amazon Agency’s CEO Being Active Online Matters for Sellers

A CEO who’s consistently present and engaging with sellers in real time is a sign of transparency, authority, and actual experience.

Even before founding My Amazon Guy, Steven Pope was already a media personality—working as a journalist, mastering communication, and building an audience. He leverages his presence to provide real, actionable insights to sellers, jumping into conversations, commenting on posts, and sharing the good, bad, and ugly of Amazon selling.

Why Does a CEO’s Online Presence Matter?

  • Transparency & Trust

An agency’s CEO should be accessible and honest. Steven Pope doesn’t hide behind polished PR—he tells it like it is, even when it’s uncomfortable. Sellers want someone who isn’t afraid to speak up about Amazon’s challenges.

  • Real-Time Industry Insights

Amazon changes every single day. A CEO who’s actively posting and engaging means their agency is ahead of the curve—adapting fast, testing new strategies, and sharing what works.

  • Direct Access to Leadership

Ever tried getting a response from a CEO with zero online presence? Good luck. When a CEO is involved and engaged, it means the agency values communication and seller success, not just closing deals.

Sellers Deserve a CEO Who’s Actually in the Trenches

If you’re choosing between an agency led by a CEO who shows up daily, engages with sellers, and actually contributes to their success versus one whose CEO is barely visible online, the choice is obvious.

But it’s not just about being present—it’s about being real.

Steven Pope doesn’t hide behind paid reputation management or scrub negative reviews—he faces criticism head-on. If he’s wrong, he owns it. If there’s a misunderstanding, he clears it up. That’s transparency, and that’s the kind of leadership Amazon sellers can trust.

Amazon Agency Related Q&As

How much does an Amazon Agency charge

Amazon agency pricing varies based on services and agency size. Full-service management typically ranges from $2,500 to $10,000+ per month, while PPC management alone can cost 10-15% of ad spend. Some agencies offer one-time audits ($500-$2,000) or hourly consulting ($200-$500 per hour). Costs depend on the agency’s expertise, service depth, and the complexity of your account.

Are there different types of Amazon agencies?

Yes, Amazon agencies come in various types:

  1. Full-Service Agencies – Manage all aspects, from account handling to PPC and SEO.
  2. PPC and Advertising Agencies – Specialize in running ad campaigns to increase sales.
  3. SEO and Listing Optimization Agencies – Focus on enhancing listings for improved visibility and rankings.
  4. Brand Management Agencies – Take care of brand strategy, protection, and trademarks.
  5. Consulting and Coaching Agencies – Provide expert advice for sellers managing their own businesses.
  6. Design and Creative Agencies – Experts in product photography and optimizing listing visuals.

Select the agency that fits your specific needs—whether it’s comprehensive service or niche expertise.

Can I succeed on Amazon without hiring an agency?

While it's possible to succeed on Amazon without an agency, entrusting your brand management to a reliable agency is generally the ideal approach for long-term success. Here’s why:

  1. Expertise – Agencies bring deep knowledge of Amazon’s algorithms, SEO, and PPC, which can save you time and boost your performance.
  2. Listing Optimization – Professionals can craft high-converting listings that stand out, improving your chances of ranking higher and driving sales.
  3. Efficient Ad Management – Agencies manage your advertising campaigns more effectively, adjusting strategies based on real-time data to maximize ROI.
  4. Customer Service & Account Health – Agencies handle complex customer service issues, keeping your account in good standing and preventing costly mistakes.
  5. Time-Saving – With experts managing your operations, you can focus on scaling your business and exploring other opportunities.

While self-management is an option, partnering with an experienced agency allows you to benefit from their specialized skills and resources, giving you a better chance to thrive on Amazon.

What do I need to prepare before hiring an Amazon agency?

Before hiring an Amazon agency, prepare the following:

  1. Clear Goals – Define your objectives (e.g., sales growth, PPC improvement).
  2. Account Data – Access your Amazon performance metrics and sales data.
  3. Product Information – Have details about your products, ASINs, listings, and inventory.
  4. Brand Guidelines – Provide any branding assets like logos or design elements.
  5. Marketing History – Share past campaigns, PPC performance, and challenges.
  6. Competitor Insights – Identify key competitors and your market position.
  7. Budget – Set a clear budget for services.
  8. Communication Preferences – Determine your preferred reporting and update schedule.

This will help ensure a smooth process and allow the agency to create a tailored strategy.

0
    0
    Your Cart
    Your cart is empty