Want to commit but still asking yourself, “Is My Amazon Guy legit?” We understand the hesitation, especially when hiring an agency is a big investment for your business.
With so many agencies promising the world but delivering little, it’s no surprise sellers feel skeptical. We know you want proof before trusting your brand with another team’s promises.
Of course, the only way to truly know is by working with us firsthand. But the next best thing we can provide is real client feedback, reviews, and documented results that prove our full-service Amazon agency delivers.
This blog breaks down whether My Amazon Guy is legit by analyzing real client feedback, reviews, and proven case studies. We’ll also share results and insights that show how our agency helps sellers grow and why we’re not a scam.
Table of Contents
Proven Results Backed by Real Sellers
We’ve helped hundreds of sellers scale profitably with full-service account management.
Why Do Sellers Ask If My Amazon Guy Is Legit?
Many sellers have been burned by agencies before, so it’s natural to be cautious when choosing a new partner. They want proof that the agency they’re investing in is credible and worth trusting.
So, it’s understandable that sellers hesitate when they see negative opinions or online noise calling My Amazon Guy a scam. Some of these posts come from real clients sharing one-sided experiences, while others are just misleading claims without proof.
This mix of genuine frustrations and false narratives fuels skepticism about the agency. That’s why showcasing real reviews, case studies, and documented results is key to showing what working with us is really like.
What Real Sellers Are Saying About My Amazon Guy
A study shows that 91% of people read customer reviews before buying a product or service, and 46% say those reviews directly influence their decisions. That’s why sharing feedback from real clients on trusted platforms is one of the strongest ways our Amazon agency can demonstrate credibility and results.
1. Trustpilot Reviews
Trustpilot is one of the most trusted review platforms sellers use when researching agencies. So it doesn’t come as a surprise that many sellers search for “Trustpilot My Amazon Guy” before availing our services, wanting to see transparent, verified feedback from real clients.
“Steven’s LinkedIn posts and videos are pure gold for anyone selling on Amazon. He breaks down complex catalog and advertising issues into simple steps you can use right away.”
"It took them a while, but they managed to reactivate my ASIN. I was impressed by their work."
“MAG came in as my agency pick of catalog experts after I fielded numerous potential agencies to resolve our issues. They have strategically worked step-by-step to resolve these issues where previously we had made little to no progress.”
On Trustpilot, clients highlight how MAG provides not just services, but also educational resources that deliver value even before working directly with the agency. Many sellers note that strategies from newsletters and videos translate into real, practical results.
Trustpilot reviews also point to MAG’s persistence in handling difficult cases like reinstatements or catalog cleanups. For sellers who’ve struggled with other agencies, these testimonials reinforce that MAG follows through and delivers measurable solutions.
2. Reddit Reviews
Reddit is not a platform dedicated to sharing reviews, but it naturally became one because users openly discuss their personal experiences and opinions on almost any topic. There are sellers who rely on these threads since they provide raw, unfiltered insights into whether an agency is worth working with.
"Steven Pope My Amazon Guy. Say what you want about him as a person / businessman, but the content he puts up on YouTube is pretty damn good."
“It was great when they set up our product on Amazon. They did everything, from handling images to filing our trademark, and it required little work from us as we focused on product development.”
"I recently worked with the team at My Amazon Guy on a critical project to reinstate an ASIN that had been flagged incorrectly. They fixed the problem and led to reinstatement. If you want to get into the Amazon space and have no experience or do not have the time to do your own research MAG is the best partner to penetrate this market"
Reddit users consistently point out that our Amazon agency delivers strong expertise in technical fixes and account management. Many highlight how Steven Pope’s free content alone provides valuable knowledge, which reinforces the company’s credibility.
Some My Amazon Guy Reddit opinions do contain negative comments, but some of these don’t provide details or proof that they came from actual clients. On the other hand, real Reddit reviews of My Amazon Guy from sellers who worked with the agency highlight successful setups, troubleshooting, and account reinstatements, showing that MAG delivers reliable expertise where it counts.
3. Google Reviews
Since 67% of consumers trust Google-based reviews the most, business owners often check them when researching agencies. These reviews are one of the best ways consumers can shape their decision about working with a service provider.
“I had an excellent experience working with MAG for our Amazon needs. Their team was incredibly responsive, knowledgeable, and proactive every step of the way.”
“My Amazon Guy handles the multitude of things that need to be done to successfully run my Amazon account and they do a great job.”
“Their communication skills are excellent—every message is clear, concise, and friendly. They’re incredibly proactive, always anticipating what’s next and keeping me informed every step of the way.”
Google reviews about MAG consistently highlight the professionalism, responsiveness, and clear communication of the team. Sellers appreciate how the agency takes the complexity out of running an Amazon business by handling critical tasks with expertise.
Clients also note that MAG’s proactive approach and fast response times set them apart from other agencies. Overall, the feedback positions MAG as a reliable partner that not only supports Amazon sellers but also helps them feel confident and well-informed throughout the process.
Want Full-Service Amazon Growth?
From PPC to SEO to catalog fixes, we handle it all so you can focus on your brand.
Documented Results: Proof in the Numbers
Positive reviews can show that sellers trust our agency, but actual performance data tells a stronger story. Hard numbers demonstrate the measurable impact of our work, proving we’re not a scam but a results-driven agency that delivers growth Amazon sellers can count on.
Case Study 1: MacuHealth
MacuHealth entered Amazon relying mostly on resellers, which hurt brand control and limited growth. After partnering with My Amazon Guy, the brand launched new products with professional listings, A+ content, and defensive ad campaigns to protect market share.
In just over a year, MacuHealth achieved a 345% sales increase and secured a spot in the top three of its supplement category. With continued ad optimization and content updates, the brand has successfully built long-term momentum on Amazon.
Case Study 2: Chirp
Chirp started with about $500k in yearly sales but struggled with positioning, conversion, and rising ad costs. Our full-service Amazon agency redefined their category placement, optimized listings with lifestyle content, and ran targeted Amazon PPC campaigns that generated $7 in return for every $1 spent.
As a result, Chirp skyrocketed to $8 million in annual sales within two years, a massive 519% growth. By reducing friction for customers and strategically expanding reach, Chirp became a top brand in the health and fitness category on Amazon.
Case Study 3: Nisolo
Before working with our Amazon agency, Nisolo faced catalog issues, poor conversion rates, and weak ad campaigns that limited growth despite a strong brand story. After our team optimized listings, fixed parentages, built A+ content, and managed PPC, Nisolo saw a 291% revenue increase in 2022.
The improvements didn’t stop at revenue because conversion rates jumped 169%, listings ranked higher through better SEO, and their store design became consistent with their brand. Nisolo’s success showcases how catalog management, creative upgrades, and strategic advertising can transform a footwear business on Amazon.
Frequently Asked Questions
Final Verdict: Is My Amazon Guy Legit?
It’s normal to be skeptical when hiring a service provider, especially when your money and business growth are on the line. Doing your research before committing is not just wise; it’s necessary.
At the same time, many negative posts online are vague opinions, while genuine feedback comes from real clients who’ve actually worked with us. With the reviews, case studies, and documented results we’ve shared, it’s clear our agency is legit and focused on delivering measurable growth for sellers.
Ready to work with an agency you can trust? Reach out to our full-service Amazon agency and see for yourself why we’re the real deal.
Work With a Trusted Amazon Agency
Don’t let doubts hold back your growth. We deliver results sellers can count on.
